Request a quote

Blog

Diesel vs Electric Fire Pumps

July 31 2024

Fire pumps play a crucial role in fire protection systems, ensuring that water is delivered at the necessary pressure to extinguish fires effectively. When it comes to choosing one, there are two types to consider, diesel vs electric fire pumps.

Each kind has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, making the choice dependent on the specific needs of your application. Today, we’ll explore the differences between diesel vs electric fire pumps, and even discuss a third option available.

Diesel Fire Pumps Overview

Triple diesel fire pump system

Diesel fire pumps operate independently of the electrical power supply, making them highly reliable during power outages. They are known for their robust power output, ensuring that they can handle demanding fire protection requirements.

Advantages of diesel fire pumps:

  • Independent of electrical power supply
  • Reliable in power outage situations
  • Variable speed

Disadvantages of diesel fire pumps:

  • Higher maintenance requirements
  • Noisier operation
  • Fuel storage and management challenges
  • Less reliable in terms of mechanical performance
  • Complex controller
  • More vibration
  • Create more heat
  • Higher cost of operation

Electric Fire Pumps Overview

Dual electric fire pump system

Electric fire pumps rely on an electrical power source, offering a quieter and generally more compact solution compared to diesel pumps. They are ideal for environments where noise and space are concerns.

Advantages of electric fire pumps:

  • Quieter operation with little vibration
  • Little maintenance requirements
  • Generally more compact
  • Easier servicing and replacement
  • Lower operating costs

Disadvantages of electric fire pumps:

  • Dependent on electrical power supply
  • Potential vulnerability during power outages unless backed by generators
  • Can’t vary speed without expensive equipment

Diesel/Electric Fire Pumps Overview

Diesel/electric fire pump system

The third option is to merge diesel and electric fire pumps into one fire protection system. Diesel/electric fire pumps combine the benefits of both power sources, providing flexibility and enhanced reliability. These systems can switch between power sources as needed, ensuring uninterrupted operation.

Advantages of diesel/electric fire pumps:

  • Flexibility and reliability with dual power sources
  • Redundancy in power supply for critical situations
  • Minimal system isolations when servicing

Disadvantages of diesel/electric fire pumps:

  • Higher initial costs due to complexity
  • More complex maintenance requirements
  • Space requirements for dual systems

Overall Comparison

Reliability

Diesel fire pumps are highly reliable during power outages, electric fire pumps depend on the availability of a stable power source, and diesel/electric fire pumps provide enhanced reliability with their dual power sources.

Maintenance

Diesel fire pumps require regular fuel checks and engine maintenance, electric fire pumps have fewer mechanical parts and thus lower maintenance needs, while diesel/electric fire pumps necessitate maintenance for both power systems, increasing complexity.

Cost

Finally, diesel fire pumps may have higher upfront and ongoing fuel costs. Conversely electric fire pumps generally have lower operational costs but can incur significant expenses if backup power systems are needed. Lastly, diesel/electric fire pumps have higher initial costs but may offer cost savings through increased reliability and efficiency.

Applications

Fire protection system on a mine site

Diesel fire pumps: Ideal for remote locations and high-reliability requirements where electrical power supply may be unstable.

Electric fire pumps: Best suited for urban areas with a stable power supply and where noise reduction is important.

Diesel/electric fire pumps: Perfect for critical infrastructure requiring maximum reliability, such as hospitals or data centres, and areas with intermittent power supply.

Explore Our Custom Fire Protection Systems

At Allied Pumps, we provide custom fire protection for a variety of industries, especially mining and commercial. Throughout the years, we have designed, manufactured, and installed fire pumps in mine sites, shopping centres, residential buildings, schools, and more.

We supply diesel, electric, and diesel/electric fire pumps with the following configurations:

  • Single diesel duty fire pump
  • Single electric duty fire pump
  • Diesel/Electric duty and standby fire pumps
  • Dual diesel duty and standby fire pumps
  • Dual electric duty and standby fire pumps
  • Triple diesel duty and standby fire pumps
  • Containerised fire protection systems
Container with fire pump inside

Our mining fire pumps are also engineered to meet the tough conditions of Australian mine sites. They feature heavy-duty frames, corrosion-resistant materials, and high-performance engines, plus they comply with the latest Australian Standards for fire protection.

Whether you need mining or commercial fire protection systems, our team can help you select the best fire pump and supply you with a custom quote.

Contact the Allied Pumps Team

Contact us to learn about how we can help you with your pump needs.

CALL US NOW EMAIL US