When it comes to positive displacement pumps, two of the most used types are gear pumps and lobe pumps. Both are reliable, efficient, and capable of handling a wide range of fluids—but they’re designed for different applications. In this guide, we break down gear pumps vs lobe pumps to help you understand how they work, where each type excels, and which one is best suited to your specific industrial needs.
Gear pumps are a type of positive displacement pump that move fluid by using the meshing action of gears. As the gears rotate, they create a vacuum at the inlet which draws fluid into the pump. The fluid is then trapped between the gear teeth and the casing, and carried around the outside of the gears to the discharge side, where it is forced out under pressure. This results in a smooth, consistent flow ideal for handling a wide range of viscosities.
There are two main types of gear pumps:
Lobe pumps are also positive displacement pumps that move fluid by trapping it between rotating lobes and the pump casing. As the lobes rotate, fluid enters the inlet side of the pump and becomes trapped in cavities formed between the lobes and the casing. The rotation then carries the fluid around the outside of the lobes to the discharge side, where it is expelled under pressure.
Lobe pumps are available in a variety of configurations, with the most common being:
Flow Rate & Pressure: Gear pumps typically offer higher pressure capabilities than lobe pumps, making them suitable for demanding applications such as chemical dosing or fuel transfer. Conversely, lobe pumps operate at lower pressures due to their non-contacting lobes and reliance on external timing gears. However, they can still provide consistent flow in low- to medium-pressure applications.
Viscosity Handling: Gear pumps are well-suited for low to moderately viscous fluids. While they can handle higher viscosities, flow rate can drop significantly as viscosity increases. Lobe pumps, on the other hand, excel in high-viscosity applications. Their large cavities and slow-speed operation allow them to move thick fluids like creams, pastes, or sludge with ease, without compromising flow.
Pulsation & Shear Sensitivity: Gear pumps produce minimal pulsation but can subject fluids to higher shear forces due to the tight clearances and gear meshing. This makes them less suitable for shear-sensitive products. Lobe pumps generate slightly more pulsation—especially in two-lobe designs—but are much gentler on fluids. Their non-contacting lobes provide low shear operation, making them ideal for delicate or shear-sensitive materials.
Wear Characteristics: Gear pumps have tight internal clearances and metal-to-metal contact between moving parts, which can lead to wear over time. However, with proper selection of materials and routine maintenance, gear pumps can offer excellent durability. Lobe Pumps, on the other hand, have non-contacting lobes that are synchronised by external timing gears. This design significantly reduces internal wear, especially in clean applications.
Ease of Cleaning: Gear pumps generally require disassembly for thorough cleaning, making them less suitable for sanitary or hygienic environments unless specially designed for clean-in-place (CIP). Conversely, lobe pumps are well-known for their hygienic design. Most models are CIP (Clean-In-Place) and SIP (Sterilise-In-Place) compatible.
Initial vs Long-Term Costs: Gear pumps generally have a lower initial purchase cost and a simple design that keeps maintenance expenses relatively low. However, in abrasive or high-wear applications, frequent part replacements can increase long-term costs. Lobe pumps are the opposite and come with a higher upfront cost due to their precision engineering, hygienic design, and CIP/SIP capabilities. However, their gentle operation and reduced wear on internal components can result in lower maintenance costs over time.
Energy Efficiency: Gear pumps are typically more energy-efficient at higher pressures and with lower viscosity fluids. Their continuous, tight-clearance operation minimises slip, resulting in less energy loss. Conversely, lobe pumps are less energy-efficient at high pressures or when handling low-viscosity fluids due to internal slip and less precise flow control. However, their efficiency improves significantly when handling thick or viscous materials at lower speeds.
Pump Downtime: Gear pumps are mechanically simple, which means fewer components to fail and typically shorter repair times. However, in abrasive or high-duty applications, their wear rate can lead to more frequent servicing. On the contrary, lobe pumps often enjoy longer lifespans in the right applications. While their maintenance may take more time due to their complexity, reduced wear often results in less unplanned downtime.
At Allied Pumps, we offer a comprehensive range of gear pumps and rotary lobe pumps to suit a variety of industrial, mining, and sanitary applications. Our in-house engineering team can assist with pump selection, system design, and custom-built packages tailored to your site conditions.
We stock a wide selection of pumps and spare parts in our warehouse, plus provide on-site and in-house pump repairs maintenance in our Canning Vale and Kalgoorlie workshops. Contact us today to find the perfect solution for your operations.
Contact us to learn about how we can help you with your pump needs.
CALL US NOW EMAIL US
